Thursday, September 16, 2010

Read-Think-Explain

Our students are learning how to respond to a test question in an essay format which they will have to apply on the Reading FCAT. This is an example of a 2-Point Short Response. Our goal is to answer this type of question in approximately five minutes. Students are to use the key words from the question and restate the question in a topic sentence. They are to answer the question and support it with details from the text. Here is a student example of a Short Response Read-Think-Explain that earned full credit, 2 points.

Why did Dad keep putting things in the wrong places? Use information and details from the story to explain your answer.

Dad kept putting things in the wrong places because he was so exhausted from waking up in the middle of the night to take care of his newborn baby daughter. As he shuffled around the house in his slippers, he tried to pick up the messes of Grandma Ana and his young son, but he was so tired that he would misplace things. For example, he put toy police cars in the refrigerator along with laundry detergent. Dad put the milk in the laundry room. Dad's sleep was disturbed by the newborn baby crying and wanting milk in the middle of the night. Dad was lacking in sleep.

Another Example:

How does the narrator MOST LIKELY feel about growing up? Use details and information from the poem to explain your answer.

The narrator most likely feels like she might miss some things about her younger days. In the text, she questions if the squirrel was glad to be up so high or if he wished he were closer to the ground. This made her think about herself growing up and leaving something behind and possibly missing something that she once enjoyed when she was younger and smaller. The narrator thinks that growing up might cause her to miss her youth.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

This sounds like great practice for the FCAT and beyond!


ANP and LMP

Anonymous said...

These are really important. You do a lot of them in middle school. Practice up. Thank you Mrs. Lopez-Sinclair and Mrs. Phillips for teaching me how to do these. Love and miss you all:)
Carly
(Camdens Amazing Sister and Phillips-Lopez alumni)

Anonymous said...

Jordan and mom found this entry very helpful. Thanks.

Sharon Snow said...

So, do the students have to have a minimum number of sentences in the response or the task to get the story information in the answer?
Thanks!

Anonymous said...

Olivia appreciates the help she is getting in creating these responses.

Dorry Lopez said...

I want to respond to all of the comments. First of all, this is great practice for the FCAT! Thank you, Carly, for your insightful comment about responding like this in Middle School. You are welcome for us teaching you how to answer an essay question! We love you, too! I am glad that our readers (Jordan and mom) are finding this helpful! Sharon, no there is not a minimum amount of sentences, but the question needs to be answered in a topic sentence, then supported with all the details possible from the text. For a short response, it should be about 3-4 sentences for a thorough response. Olivia, I am so glad that you are so appreciative of this help!

Love,
Mrs. Lopez-Sinclair

Anonymous said...

maddie 8

i love read think expains but the large ones are hard.

Anonymous said...

from this infromaton i think i can ace reading test and fcat thank you

Anonymous said...

that sounds like a great practice for the fcat